Review Detail

What worked:
The first unique aspect of the book is that it’s based on the culture of Kazakhstan. Kazakh vocabulary is introduced early on with Batu referring to his grandmother as his azhe, salemtsiz be is a Kazakh greeting, and bauyrsaq is a fried dough. Batu sits on the threshold of his apartment during the Kazakh new year called Nauryz which opens a doorway between worlds. That’s how he meets Aspara who’s been dead for over two thousand years and wants his help in finding the Golden Cup. Additional Kazakh folklore and history are a large part of the story that includes Kazakhstan’s past conflicts with Russia.
Batu is an interesting character as he struggles with self-confidence. A bully is extorting money from him and Batu is terrified to stand up for himself. Then, Aspara shows up and says Batu is a brave warrior. Batu lies when Aspara asks about his abilities while silently concealing his cowardice. This internal conflict lingers throughout the plot and is never far from Batu’s thoughts. Batu respects his elders and the traditions of his culture and these qualities, along with the bravery buried inside, will help him become an honorable warrior.
The plot offers unexpected twists to add new levels of complications. The bully pops up at school and at Batu’s apartment and he uses a large classmate as his muscle. It turns out there’s more to the bully’s efforts than what’s first seen and his henchman becomes a bigger part of the story than anticipated. In addition, Batu’s mother is in the hospital giving birth to a baby sister in what seems to be an unimportant side story. However, this event turns out to be more significant as Batu is forced to make some difficult decisions.
What didn’t work as well:
Batu’s character displays some conflicting behaviors that don’t always make sense. He’s transforming into a brave, honorable warrior in search of the Golden Cup but he then gloats and taunts a bully and later has angry, insulting outbursts toward his friends. Also, based on the book’s title, the ending will probably leave readers unsatisfied and confused.
The Final Verdict:
Using Kazakhstan as the setting and its culture as the basis for the story provides freshness in the middle-grade genre. The use of Kazakh folklore creates a familiar format to the plot with unique details sprinkled in. Despite the questionable ending, the overall book is interesting.