The Wall and the Wild

The Wall and the Wild
Co-Authors / Illustrators
Age Range
4+
Release Date
September 07, 2021
ISBN
978-1913747435
Buy This Book
      
When Ana tries to take control by creating a perfect garden, she comes to realize that nature is inherently wild.

In a plot of land at the edge of town, Ana grows only perfectly sized plants and perfect-looking flowers; she throws all the irregular shoots and uneven seeds over the wall into the disorderly Wild. But as her garden gets tidier, neater and more constrained, the Wild begins to grow…

Editor review

1 review
thought-provoking picture book read
Overall rating
 
5.0
Plot/Characters/Writing Style
 
5.0
Illustrations/Photos (if applicable)
 
5.0
THE WALL AND THE WILD is an intriguing picture book read about beauty, perfectionism, and gardening. Ana lives at the edge of the wild, and she has decided to grow a garden. Ana is very particular about which seeds she will plant and where they will go. She throws the seeds she does not want to use into the wild and separates her garden from the wild with a wall. As her garden begins to grow, animals and people take notice of its beauty, but Ana notices the plants that shouldn't be there, plucking them out and tossing into the wild. Eventually, the wild has grown into something beautiful where the animals and people now want to be, while Ana's garden is constrained. Ana ends by tearing down the wall.

What I loved: This was an intriguing and thought-provoking picture book read with a story that seems simple on the surface but presents some themes that merit further consideration. For instance, the plants that Ana tosses away could be considered her failures or mistaken attempts - but she later learns that they also created something truly beautiful. Her quest for perfection also leads to something other than what she wanted to create - with the imperfection of the wild holding the most beauty. And, of course, there are implications for what makes a beautiful garden and how beauty is judged and by whom.

The story itself is simple and captures the imagination, and the accompanying illustrations are expressive with a lot of color and lovely flowers growing throughout. The backmatter also adds some interesting learning points about variety and ecosystems, as they need a lot of different things to thrive with other implications for the world and communities. This would definitely be a great one to discuss with children and would work well in a classroom with talking about (or starting) a garden. What would they choose to grow in their garden?

Final verdict: An intriguing and thought-provoking picture book read, THE WALL AND THE WILD tells the story of Ana, her quest for perfection, and the lessons she learns along the way. Recommend for elementary school aged readers.
Report this review Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.
Already have an account? or Create an account