this bookwasn't so much confusing as it was just plain bad. were set on an island where the people like to talk and outsiders aren't welcomed. it's weird but this book to me was just about the iimportance and effects of gossip more than the tantalizing issue facing caitlin. although one finds out that cait has feelings for the mysterious lucas, the fact that so little is known about him begs to question whether the atuhor did it on purpose or if wer are to piece together the bits of information given. i thought the book was fairly bad in it's events although i enjoyed reading the transformation of the relationdhip between dom and cait. it's great to see brothers and sister getting along. i just wish that lucas didn't have to be so mysterious.