I must agree with some of the other reviews I have read, this book was definately a disappointment. To me, it all seemed a little predictable and there was no suspense or thrill. It was a good book, just not too entertaining. Part of my questions the reasoning behind Meyers' continuation of the series. If she wrote it because she wanted to and had the inspiration or because her editors wanted it or the simple fact that majority of the readers wanted a happy ending for Jacob. This book seemed to drag to me and I read it not to enjoy it, but to simply finish it. The first three of the Twilight Saga I would reccomend but this is not something to get too excited about.