This was a great book! the tension between Edward and Jacob really built up the suspense. I really wasn't sure if I wanted Bella to choose Edward or Jacob, although I was pretty sure who she was going to choose. I never would have guessed though that Bella was in love with Jacob.That just made the goodbye harder. the epilogue in Jacob's point of view made me cry. it was so sad to see how he felt. I hope Jake imprints soon so he doesn't feel so depressed.
The only things that I think detracted from this book was that Bella was so whiny and thought everything was her fault and that Edward Really lost his personality. Other than that the book was PERFECT!
Everyone should read Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse (in that order) they are geat,but sad and romantic.