Gilt Featured

http://www.yabookscentral.com/media/reviews/photos/thumbnail/200x275s/ce/1e/82/11836_Gilt_1333059298.jpg
 
3.7
 
4.1 (3)
1478   0
Age Range
12+
Release Date
May 15, 2012
ISBN
978-0670013999
Buy This Book
      

When Kitty Tylney's best friend, Catherine Howard, worms her way into King Henry VIII's heart and brings Kitty to court, she's thrust into a world filled with fabulous gowns, sparkling jewels, and elegant parties. No longer stuck in Cat's shadow, Kitty's now caught between two men--the object of her affection and the object of her desire. But court is also full of secrets, lies, and sordid affairs, and as Kitty witnesses Cat's meteoric rise and fall as queen, she must figure out how to keep being a good friend when the price of telling the truth could literally be her head.

Editor reviews

In this historical fiction work, the “romance,” flirting, lust, deceit, and manipulation—all in the name of power—is virtually unceasing. At the outset, Katherine Longshore plunges the reader into the 15th century court of King Henry VIII. Most have heard about his numerous wives and the scandals and beheadings surrounding his reign, but this book makes the characters and their stories come alive.

Katherine (Kitty) Tylney is the story’s pushover main character, bosom friend of Catherine (Cat) Howard, a girl who makes it her life’s goal to have fun, gain power, and live only for herself, regardless of who she hurts on her way. I identified with Kitty at some times, recognizing the feelings of being ignored while close friends get all the attention; the heady elation felt when you, the invisible one, are finally noticed; and the strong inner emotions of discovering betrayal and the self-deprecation that comes when you let something happen that you knew would bring terrible consequences.

The author tries to stay true to history as much as possible while weaving an intriguing story, and so because of that, Kitty remains invisible and does not move history as I hoped she would. She lets Cat, and others, walk all over her. She has an inner strength that she rarely lets shine. Knowing her strength and seeing her continue to stifle it over and over again was emotionally draining! I wanted to see Kitty defend herself—wondered when she would stand up for herself, but it almost never happens. It was this desire to see her rise up and fight for the good in this story that made me keep turning the pages. In spite of the continuous disappointment (which, in the end, is inevitable if Longshore was to stay true to historical facts), the book drew me in because the main characters were so well-written.

There are several characters who, though primary, fell flat (I kept getting Alice and Joan mixed up and couldn’t really ‘see’ them in my mind), but the other characters’ depth is what overshadowed them.

One caveat is the almost unending web of sexual manipulation, innuendo, and promiscuity. There are not graphic sex scenes (although there is a rape scene, it is not written in full detail—only describes the horrific nature of it) but continuous sexual language and lust. This ties into the destructive nature of Cat’s (and others’) life—the pursuit of sex and power and riches leads only to…nothing. The hollow pursuits of almost every person in this story bring to light the reality of their consequences. In the end I think it is obvious how much of a waste Catherine’s life ended up being, and it is sadly eye-opening. Because of this, I think this book should a) not be read by girls younger than say, 15—and read with discussion following—and, b) could be helpful in that it shows how living only for yourself and pursuing sex, riches, and power lead to naught. I finished feeling deeply in my heart how important it is to make life so much MORE than this—and I think this book could show teenagers the same. It will leave the reader thinking, “Who cares about jewels and riches and lust—I want deep, real relationship, honesty, and meaning in my life.”
Overall rating 
 
3.7
Plot 
 
3.0
Characters 
 
3.0
Writing Style 
 
5.0
Nicholette Tilghman, Editor Reviewed by Nicholette Tilghman, Editor May 12, 2012
Last updated: May 15, 2012
Top 50 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews (120)

Thought provoking page-turner

In this historical fiction work, the “romance,” flirting, lust, deceit, and manipulation—all in the name of power—is virtually unceasing. At the outset, Katherine Longshore plunges the reader into the 15th century court of King Henry VIII. Most have heard about his numerous wives and the scandals and beheadings surrounding his reign, but this book makes the characters and their stories come alive.

Katherine (Kitty) Tylney is the story’s pushover main character, bosom friend of Catherine (Cat) Howard, a girl who makes it her life’s goal to have fun, gain power, and live only for herself, regardless of who she hurts on her way. I identified with Kitty at some times, recognizing the feelings of being ignored while close friends get all the attention; the heady elation felt when you, the invisible one, are finally noticed; and the strong inner emotions of discovering betrayal and the self-deprecation that comes when you let something happen that you knew would bring terrible consequences.

The author tries to stay true to history as much as possible while weaving an intriguing story, and so because of that, Kitty remains invisible and does not move history as I hoped she would. She lets Cat, and others, walk all over her. She has an inner strength that she rarely lets shine. Knowing her strength and seeing her continue to stifle it over and over again was emotionally draining! I wanted to see Kitty defend herself—wondered when she would stand up for herself, but it almost never happens. It was this desire to see her rise up and fight for the good in this story that made me keep turning the pages. In spite of the continuous disappointment (which, in the end, is inevitable if Longshore was to stay true to historical facts), the book drew me in because the main characters were so well-written.

There are several characters who, though primary, fell flat (I kept getting Alice and Joan mixed up and couldn’t really ‘see’ them in my mind), but the other characters’ depth is what overshadowed them.

One caveat is the almost unending web of sexual manipulation, innuendo, and promiscuity. There are not graphic sex scenes (although there is a rape scene, it is not written in full detail—only describes the horrific nature of it) but continuous sexual language and lust. This ties into the destructive nature of Cat’s (and others’) life—the pursuit of sex and power and riches leads only to…nothing. The hollow pursuits of almost every person in this story bring to light the reality of their consequences. In the end I think it is obvious how much of a waste Catherine’s life ended up being, and it is sadly eye-opening. Because of this, I think this book should a) not be read by girls younger than say, 15—and read with discussion following—and, b) could be helpful in that it shows how living only for yourself and pursuing sex, riches, and power lead to naught. I finished feeling deeply in my heart how important it is to make life so much MORE than this—and I think this book could show teenagers the same. It will leave the reader thinking, “Who cares about jewels and riches and lust—I want deep, real relationship, honesty, and meaning in my life.”

Was this review helpful to you? 
 

User reviews

Average user rating from: 3 user(s)

Already have an account? or Create an account
Overall rating 
 
4.1
Plot 
 
4.3  (3)
Characters 
 
4.0  (3)
Writing Style 
 
4.0  (3)
I was really going through a historical fiction kick for a minute there so when I heard about this book, I jumped at the chance to read it. Tudor history is always interesting and filled with drama and deceit, of which, this book did not disappoint. However, I wasn’t too drawn into the book as a whole.
I felt that everything was a bit too drawn out, possibly too much detail went into the setting and time that I could’ve done without. I understand Katherine Longshore wanted to establish a setting and clue those in who aren’t too familiar with history, but it got to the point where I found myself skipping over paragraphs and basically only reading the dialogue, which I tend to do when a book bores me.

I’d have to say probably the only thing that kept me going was the drama that Catherine Howard created and I wanted to know how and when she would meet her ultimate demise. True to her character, I knew exactly how her life would go and where it would end up and found her to be more interesting than Kitty, the narrator of the story. Even though Kitty is a sweet, innocent character, utterly loyal to Catherine until the end, I wasn’t really drawn to her character. The ending was a bit predictable, since it is learned history, and nothing in the book really stood out to me in any way.

Overall, Longshore does a great job in staying true to historical facts, painting a vivid picture of history, and inciting intrigue, but the story as a whole failed to capture my attention and I basically skimming it until the end.
Overall rating 
 
2.7
Plot 
 
3.0
Characters 
 
3.0
Writing Style 
 
2.0
Vi, Editor Reviewed by Vi, Editor August 14, 2012
Top 50 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews (67)

Filled with drama and intrigue, but too drawn out and a bit boring at times

I was really going through a historical fiction kick for a minute there so when I heard about this book, I jumped at the chance to read it. Tudor history is always interesting and filled with drama and deceit, of which, this book did not disappoint. However, I wasn’t too drawn into the book as a whole.
I felt that everything was a bit too drawn out, possibly too much detail went into the setting and time that I could’ve done without. I understand Katherine Longshore wanted to establish a setting and clue those in who aren’t too familiar with history, but it got to the point where I found myself skipping over paragraphs and basically only reading the dialogue, which I tend to do when a book bores me.

I’d have to say probably the only thing that kept me going was the drama that Catherine Howard created and I wanted to know how and when she would meet her ultimate demise. True to her character, I knew exactly how her life would go and where it would end up and found her to be more interesting than Kitty, the narrator of the story. Even though Kitty is a sweet, innocent character, utterly loyal to Catherine until the end, I wasn’t really drawn to her character. The ending was a bit predictable, since it is learned history, and nothing in the book really stood out to me in any way.

Overall, Longshore does a great job in staying true to historical facts, painting a vivid picture of history, and inciting intrigue, but the story as a whole failed to capture my attention and I basically skimming it until the end.

Was this review helpful to you? 
Gilt takes you back to Tudor times and shows you Cat Howard before and while she was married to King Henry through the eyes of her best friend. This books gives of pieces of history will also telling the friend, Kitty's story. In a world where no one wants them, Cat decides to take what she wants, while Kitty is merely her shadow. As Cat becomes Queen and moves her friends to court, Kitty slowly grows into her own woman. This story was heartbreaking and beautifully written.
Overall rating 
 
5.0
Plot 
 
5.0
Characters 
 
5.0
Writing Style 
 
5.0
Brittany Reviewed by Brittany August 02, 2012
Top 50 Reviewer  -   View all my reviews (72)

Lovely read

Gilt takes you back to Tudor times and shows you Cat Howard before and while she was married to King Henry through the eyes of her best friend. This books gives of pieces of history will also telling the friend, Kitty's story. In a world where no one wants them, Cat decides to take what she wants, while Kitty is merely her shadow. As Cat becomes Queen and moves her friends to court, Kitty slowly grows into her own woman. This story was heartbreaking and beautifully written.

Was this review helpful to you? 
This review begins with a confession. Intrigued? Here we go. Confession #1: I cheated on King Henry. Oh wait, that wasn't me! That was Catherine (like that narrows it down). Oops! I got ahead of myself. Actually, my confession is that, much as I love reading historical fiction, I really am not a huge fan of reading about the Tudors. They're a completely fascinating (i.e. batshit insane) family, especially during Henry VIII's reign. However, I have been burned by books and movies about these years before. I know everyone else loved The Other Boleyn Girl but both the book and the film were big fat DNFs for me. Because of this, I enter every Tudors thing with a larger than usual (and usual is prodigious) amount of skepticism. Well, this one I loved.

One thing that often frustrates me about the Tudors, even the show (which I largely enjoyed) is the romanticizing of Henry. Partly, this is because he tends to be younger in much of the fiction, a lot of which focuses on Anne Boleyn. I'm not saying Henry doesn't come off as a womanizing bastard (he does), but he also generally seems like he gets so much play because he's attractive and charismatic. Again, I think that was fairly true when he was young, although I definitely think much of his appeal had to do with the crown even then. However, as he got older, he got fat and had serious health issues. I love Katherine Longshore for displaying Henry as what he really was.

I totally get why shows make Henry more attractive (who wants to watch some guy who looks like that?), but that doesn't make it accurate, and there's less of a reason for it in fiction. That seems unfair to say, but oh well. The same is true of Catherine, who is portrayed as a completely fetching blonde in the show, but pictures reveal her to be somewhat plain. In Gilt, Cat is described not as beautiful, but as vivacious and so charming no one can tell that she's not gorgeous.

What really drew me into Gilt, though, is Kitty. I identified so much with Kitty and her desperation. She has nobody and she wants so badly to believe that she has a real friend in Cat. She is loyal to a fault (a big one). For the most part, I really am not like Kitty, but I liked Kitty so much, and I just kept hoping she would make the right decisions such as avoiding ruinous people.

There are so many right bastards (both literally and figuratively I'm sure) walking around Henry's court. Women's options were so incredibly limited. Of course, there were also the freedoms that they had. I cannot believe how easy it was for women to be, well, easy. Even in a dormitory packed full of beds, with more than one girl per bed no less, girls managed to carry out affairs; there's nothing awkward about that. Don't even get me started on the rage I feel about how men could rape any woman they wanted to and claim that she wanted it, so obviously it's her fault. Instead, I will let Kitty send that message in my favorite quote. I love her when she has a backbone.

Gilt is truly wonderful. I laughed, I was grossed out, I was enraged and I nearly cried. Gilt really is a lot like a more historically accurate, YA version of The Tudors. There's sex, backstabbing and dirty jokes galore. I loved every single minute of it. If you enjoy reading all of those things, get thee to a bookstore anon!
Overall rating 
 
4.7
Plot 
 
5.0
Characters 
 
4.0
Writing Style 
 
5.0

My Favorite Tudors Fiction

This review begins with a confession. Intrigued? Here we go. Confession #1: I cheated on King Henry. Oh wait, that wasn't me! That was Catherine (like that narrows it down). Oops! I got ahead of myself. Actually, my confession is that, much as I love reading historical fiction, I really am not a huge fan of reading about the Tudors. They're a completely fascinating (i.e. batshit insane) family, especially during Henry VIII's reign. However, I have been burned by books and movies about these years before. I know everyone else loved The Other Boleyn Girl but both the book and the film were big fat DNFs for me. Because of this, I enter every Tudors thing with a larger than usual (and usual is prodigious) amount of skepticism. Well, this one I loved.

One thing that often frustrates me about the Tudors, even the show (which I largely enjoyed) is the romanticizing of Henry. Partly, this is because he tends to be younger in much of the fiction, a lot of which focuses on Anne Boleyn. I'm not saying Henry doesn't come off as a womanizing bastard (he does), but he also generally seems like he gets so much play because he's attractive and charismatic. Again, I think that was fairly true when he was young, although I definitely think much of his appeal had to do with the crown even then. However, as he got older, he got fat and had serious health issues. I love Katherine Longshore for displaying Henry as what he really was.

I totally get why shows make Henry more attractive (who wants to watch some guy who looks like that?), but that doesn't make it accurate, and there's less of a reason for it in fiction. That seems unfair to say, but oh well. The same is true of Catherine, who is portrayed as a completely fetching blonde in the show, but pictures reveal her to be somewhat plain. In Gilt, Cat is described not as beautiful, but as vivacious and so charming no one can tell that she's not gorgeous.

What really drew me into Gilt, though, is Kitty. I identified so much with Kitty and her desperation. She has nobody and she wants so badly to believe that she has a real friend in Cat. She is loyal to a fault (a big one). For the most part, I really am not like Kitty, but I liked Kitty so much, and I just kept hoping she would make the right decisions such as avoiding ruinous people.

There are so many right bastards (both literally and figuratively I'm sure) walking around Henry's court. Women's options were so incredibly limited. Of course, there were also the freedoms that they had. I cannot believe how easy it was for women to be, well, easy. Even in a dormitory packed full of beds, with more than one girl per bed no less, girls managed to carry out affairs; there's nothing awkward about that. Don't even get me started on the rage I feel about how men could rape any woman they wanted to and claim that she wanted it, so obviously it's her fault. Instead, I will let Kitty send that message in my favorite quote. I love her when she has a backbone.

Gilt is truly wonderful. I laughed, I was grossed out, I was enraged and I nearly cried. Gilt really is a lot like a more historically accurate, YA version of The Tudors. There's sex, backstabbing and dirty jokes galore. I loved every single minute of it. If you enjoy reading all of those things, get thee to a bookstore anon!

Was this review helpful to you? 
 
Powered by JReviews

LATEST YABC BLOG POSTS - BLOG TOURS, ANNOUNCEMENTS, AND GIVEAWAYS

View more blog entries

Latest Book Listings Added

Category: Young Adult Indie
The Men in the Trees centers around a teen mother, Meryl Panagos, who’s barely out of high school, living on...
 
0.0
 
0.0 (0)
Michael completed the Path. What he found at the end turned everything he’d ever known about his life—and the...
 
4.3
 
0.0 (0)
Greg Gaines is the last master of high school espionage, able to disappear at will into any social environment. He...
 
4.7
 
0.0 (0)
Every little girl goes through her princess phase, whether she wants to be Snow White or Cinderella, Belle or Ariel....
 
4.7
 
0.0 (0)
“Happy birthday, child. Careful not to shoot any grundwirgen.” Ever since she was a small girl, she has learned to...
 
4.3
 
0.0 (0)
This quirky, narrative scrapbook gives readers a witty, honest look at what it means to be a teenager.Using mini-graphic novels,...
 
3.5
 
0.0 (0)
In Bed Stuy, New York, a small misunderstanding can escalate into having a price on your head—even if you’re totally...
 
4.7
 
0.0 (0)
The Jewel means wealth. The Jewel means beauty. The Jewel means royalty. But for girls like Violet, the Jewel means...
 
3.3
 
3.7 (1)
From the author of Fault Line comes an edgy and heartbreaking novel about two self-destructive teens in a Sid and...
 
4.7
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
Sammy Keyes has spent the last few years solving other people's mysteries; now her friends (and some foes) come together...
 
5.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
Charlie and Tommy have big plans for Halloween. They hope to get out of taking their little sisters around and...
 
4.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
The reading scores at Ella Mentry School are way down, so Mr. Macky has decided to hire a special new...
 
5.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
A.J. and the gang from My Weird School star in this special series of after-school, holiday-themed chapter books featuring all-new...
 
5.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
Stanley is working at his garage today. From filling up Hattie's red sports car with gas to changing the tire...
 
4.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
When Stanley's friend Myrtle buys a plot of land, she asks Stanley to build her a new house. He works...
 
4.0
 
0.0 (0)
In Julie Kagawa's groundbreaking modern fantasy series, dragons walk among us in human form. Long ago, dragons were hunted to...
 
4.3
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
As the junior concierge at her father's posh hotel, thirteen-year-old Chloe escorts three troublemaking royals on their trip to New...
 
5.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
It's 1926, and the one thing eleven-year-old Lexie Lewis wants more than anything is to leave Portland, where she is...
 
0.0
 
0.0 (0)
Category: Kids Fiction
When an earthquake causes the deadly band of air that covers the post World War III Earth to begin to...
 
4.0
 
0.0 (0)
In 1959 Virginia, the lives of two girls on opposite sides of the battle for civil...
 
4.0
 
4.0 (1)